HMC Chair Fiona Boulton will reveal new evidence showing voters, including previous Labour supporters, want parental choice and access to independent schools.
Following the Labour Party conference motion to abolish independent schools outright or destroy them through punitive taxation, HMC Chair Fiona Boulton will reveal the following ComRes findings in her first speech:
Two thirds (68%) of the public think parents should be able to pay for their children’s education if they can afford it. Only one in five (18%) disagree. Over half (56%) of Labour voters agree, as do 83% of Conservative voters and 70% of Lib Dem voters
Nearly half (49%) of respondents support a Government policy to help pay for children from lower income backgrounds to attend independent schools. Only 27% are not in favour. 46% of Labour voters support this policy, alongside 52% of Conservative and 47% of Lib Dem voters
More people distrust government and local councils to run schools effectively than trust them. 35% trusted them to do so compared to two in five (41%) who distrust them. 41% of Labour voters trust central Government or local council to run schools effectively whilst 36% of Conservative voters and 35% of Lib Dem voters say the same.
The findings come as parents, state school heads and commentators join the backlash against the Labour policy passed at conference to seize land and assets from independent schools and “integrate” them into the state sector. The motion resolved to start by withdrawing charitable status, charging multiple taxes and imposing quotas on universities based on school type rather than social background or academic ability.
Guildford High School head Mrs Boulton, who is the second female Chair of HMC and the first to run an all-girls school, will address nearly 300 of the UK’s leading independent school heads at HMC’s 150th anniversary conference. She will say that a “different conversation” is needed, in which “there is no limit to aspiration for any child” and “we fight alongside each other in the pursuit of a privileged childhood for all.”
“We stand proud of our contribution to education in this country. This is a time for inclusion, acceptance and friendship and a time to inspire harmony,” she will tell conference.
“Voters want the government to help more children to get access to independent schools. Parents are ambitious for their children and people want to see our schools opening up, not closing down.
“This tells us that the policy of destroying great independent schools is a vote loser. The political activists who want to tax good schools to death without a notion of how to nurture achievement elsewhere, do not understand the common sense of the British people.
“Educators, not politicians, should be in charge of schools, is the message from voters – and so say all of us. As leaders of independent schools we need to keep listening and learning. But it seems that independence and choice are concepts which never go out of fashion.
“And do not be fooled into thinking that imposing crippling taxes is anything other than abolition by the back door. It would ensure that many independent schools would not survive and others will become more expensive. State schools will see larger class sizes and burgeoning costs.
“The decision taken by Labour conference to abolish our schools was based on ignorance and the desire to damage, whilst independent schools have for years been quietly educating children, alongside creating free and discounted places, sponsoring successful academies and delivering more than 5,000 helpful projects in state schools communities.”
Mrs Boulton will describe how the independent sector has offered up to 10,000 places a year free of charge to lower income families. This is based on a model of joint funding, in which the government pays what it would cost to send each child to a state school, and the independent school pays the rest.
“We have always been open to discussing jointly funded places or other open-access approaches that might work, opening up our schools even more, providing new life chances and taking further pressure off state schools.
“It is encouraging that this poll shows such high levels of support for such a collaborative, positive measure – including amongst Labour voters.”
Mike Buchanan, Executive Director of HMC, said:
‘This survey reveals a remarkable gulf between the Labour party’s official policy to abolish or punitively tax independent schools and the views of those who voted Labour just two years ago.
"It also underlines the public belief that parents should be free to make choices for their children, including paying for their child’s education rather than asking the state to do so.
"It is striking that the findings suggest the public is in no mood to uproot a valued national asset, and many would like to see the benefits offered by independent schools made even more widely available.
“This a view driven by common sense and compassion rather than ideology. All politicians would do well to heed it.”
Mrs Boulton’s speech comes as teachers from across the sectors demonstrate their lack of support for harming independent schools.
- A survey of more than 5,000 teachers who take part in TeacherTapp polls found only 9% wanted to ban independent schools outright (weighted poll to ensure it is representative)
- Dave Benson, head of award-winning Kensington Aldridge Academy at the base of Grenfell Tower, has called Labour’s policy “misguided”, “troubling” and says it will not help his pupils https://www.tes.com/news/grenfell-head-abolishing-private-schools-misguided
- General Secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders Geoff Barton has cast doubt on the idea that harming independent schools will improve social mobility https://www.tes.com/news/why-abolishing-private-schools-ethically-dubious
Notes to editors
- Methodology: ComRes interviewed 2,016 GB adults online between between 6th and 8th September 2019. Data were weighted to be nationally representative of all GB adults by age, gender, region and social grade. ComRes is a member of the British Polling Council and abides by its rules. The raw data was provided with this press notice and will be available online from 00.01 Sept 30th via this link: https://www.comresglobal.com/our-work/poll-archive/
- The voting decisions of respondents in the 2017 general election was captured in the poll
- HMC (the Headmasters' & Headmistresses' Conference) is a professional association of heads of the world's leading independent schools. HMC has 296 members in the British Isles educating more than 200,000 children, plus international members. Our members lead schools that are distinguished by their excellence in pastoral care, co-curricular provision and classroom teaching. Members of HMC have met annually in conference virtually every year since the first meeting in 1869. HMC today is a thriving, pro-active Association of leading figures in school education. See hmc.org.uk.